Minor sports getting squeezed out at HBCUs
Juggling money and Title IX requirements often puts baseball, men’s track, golf and bowling in jeopardy
When Clark Atlanta University announced this summer that it was suspending its men’s track and field program, alarms were sounded in some corners of the historically black colleges and universities landscape — as well in the community at large.
Here is a school in Atlanta, which hosted the Summer Olympics just 20 years ago. Those games featured gold medal-winning sprinter Michael Johnson and long jumper Carl Lewis.
Was there not sufficient momentum built to sustain a viable track and field program for at least a couple of generations?
Isn’t there an almost unlimited number of potential men in the Atlanta area alone who can run and jump?
As it turns out, the truth is much more complicated, according to commissioners and athletic directors responsible for managing the musical chairs known as HBCU athletics.
It comes down to money and Title IX
But what it mainly boils down to are two things: money and Title IX, the federal law that mandates gender equity in college athletics.
And what happened at Clark Atlanta, a member of the Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (SIAC), is not much different from what has happened, particularly over the past five years, with schools in other predominantly black conferences. In the last five years, more than a dozen sports, mainly of the nonrevenue variety, have been dropped or suspended by the Mid-Eastern Athletic Conference (MEAC), Southwestern Athletic Conference (SWAC), Central Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (CIAA) and the SIAC, according to information gathered from the conferences and in discussions and correspondence with athletic administrators at the schools.
Before that, schools across the board, facing lower enrollments and shrinking budgets, had already begun reshaping their sports lineups, because noncompliance with Title IX could mean a loss of federal dollars for both public and private colleges and universities.
“The overarching issue is not HBCU athletic departments dropping sports,” said SWAC commissioner Duer Sharp. “We must first acknowledge that the business model for college athletics has changed, and lower-revenue institutions — not just HBCUs — are fighting to financially withstand some of those changes.”
The chain reaction is that HBCUs are facing stiffer competition for students from predominantly white mid-major institutions looking to keep all their numbers in balance.
The end result is an elimination and shifting of sports programs.
In the Division I SWAC, the only recent programs reported to be discontinued are men’s and women’s golf at Mississippi Valley State University, according to Jasher Cox, SWAC director of communications. But the school is hoping to bring back men’s and women’s tennis, which were discontinued several years ago, Cox said.
In the Division I MEAC, according to Brian Howard, the MEAC’s assistant director of media relations:
- North Carolina A&T State University dropped women’s swimming after last season;
- University of Maryland Eastern Shore dropped men’s tennis;
- Hampton University dropped women’s bowling in 2016;
- North Carolina Central University dropped women’s bowling a year ago.
Declining enrollment, and the accompanying loss of dollars, plus decreased federal and state funding, contributes to budget woes that led to the elimination of some sports.
“Three out of the five states that host our schools have faced significant budgets cuts,” Sharp said. “A lot of HBCUs simply don’t have the resources to absorb the financial cuts and losses as well as the larger schools.”
The problems might get worse for Division I HBCUs. With the College Football Playoff and a greater emphasis on strength of schedule for major conferences, black colleges might soon get squeezed out of the so-called “road-kill” games that pay them $100,000 to $200,000 per game.
Those contests often provided a big chunk of the budget for HBCUs, which have spending levels of $4 million to $10 million, meaning in some cases an entire program’s budget is less than the salary of a Power 5 conference coach.
In the Division II CIAA:
- Winston-Salem State University has suspended men’s golf, men’s track and field, men’s tennis and women’s bowling;
- Elizabeth City State University has suspended baseball but is planning to revive it soon.
A few other schools have made adjustments with women’s bowling and men’s tennis, according to CIAA director of communications Adrian Ferguson.
Currently, only five schools play baseball in the CIAA — Winston-Salem State, Chowan University, St. Augustine’s University, Virginia State University and Lincoln University — which is not enough to earn its champion an automatic bid in NCAA tournament play.
“Baseball is on the watch for us,” CIAA commissioner Jacqie McWilliams said Thursday in Durham, North Carolina, where she spoke during CIAA football media day. “Men’s tennis is a concern. I am concerned about the men’s sports in our conference.”
Winston-Salem State athletics director Tonia Walker said it’s a balancing act.
“Your athletics have to mirror enrollment,” she said. “If you have 70 percent women enrolled, you have to reflect that in athletics.”
Title IX mandates that universities provide participation opportunities for women and men that are substantially proportionate to their respective rates of enrollment of full-time undergraduate students, according to the NCAA website.
Declining male college enrollment, while female enrollment increases, makes complying with Title IX more challenging.
Then there is the elephant in the room: football.
“Anytime you have football, it presents a situation where it’s hard to have that balance,” Walker said, because no women’s programs have a roster as large as a football roster.
That’s why it’s typical in the CIAA for a school to have four to five men’s sports compared with six or seven women’s sports.
Overall declining enrollment comes into play also, as minority students are getting more opportunities to play at predominantly white mid-major schools.
Add to that declining federal dollars for education, and a potentially volatile mix is in play.
Still, McWilliams, who is also chairman of the Division II Management Council, cautioned against using Title IX as an excuse.
“Title IX doesn’t mean that you get rid of sports; it means you can add sports,” McWilliams said. “I don’t like when people say we cut sports because of Title IX; that’s not why you cut sports. You don’t have the resources to manage your program.”
She said Title IX also gives schools a chance to be creative, such as adding sports such as soccer.
Sharp said the SWAC is looking at mixed team sports, as well as emerging sports for women, such as equestrian and fencing.
Cutting sports is not an easy decision
In the Division II SIAC:
- Clark Atlanta dropped men’s track and field;
- Miles College dropped men’s track and field after the 2011-12 season;
- Paine College dropped football after the 2014-15 season;
- Lane College dropped men’s and women’s cross-country after the 2015-16 season.
“Suspending or reducing a varsity sport is not an easy decision,” said Clark Atlanta athletic director J. Lin Dawson in a statement on the school’s website. “The decision to right-size the department was based on resources, competitiveness, gender equity and facilities.”
Clark Atlanta’s enrollment of 3,500 students is 74 percent women.
In 2016, the SIAC added Central State University in Wilberforce, Ohio, as a full member before the 2015 season. The Marauders had become an associate member for football only in 2013, after it became a charter member of the Great Midwest Athletic Conference in 2012, which did not sponsor football.
Central State was able to revive football in 2005 with the help of some of its NFL alumni, such as Hugh Douglas, a former Philadelphia Eagles linebacker.
The team finished 5-5 in its first full season of SIAC play.
But the bigger concern is when a conference loses a sport.
“In the case of HBCUs,” said SIAC commissioner Gregory Moore, “the impacts are particularly troubling when you consider the enormous contributions black colleges make to advance the cause of diversity and inclusion.
“Although HBCUs make up approximately 5 percent of NCAA institutions, 32 out of 38 NCAA Division II African-American head football coaches for example [almost 90 percent] are employed at HBCUs.
“So when an HBCU institution drops a sport, it’s not simply a loss of an invaluable participation opportunity for our student-athletes, but very often a person of color has also lost a coaching opportunity at a time when we desperately need more minority and women coaches — not less.”
McWilliams said the CIAA is looking at possible expansion and adding an “associate membership,” where a school would compete in certain sports, such as baseball, to get the conference to the required six teams for its champion to qualify for an automatic NCAA tournament bid.
Beyond athletics, McWilliams said, many schools across the country are facing financial challenges because of decreases in state and federal funding.
“So the conversation will never go away,” she said. Down the road, she added, “some schools might not have the finances to keep more than 10, which is required at their institution.”
Moore of the SIAC agrees.
“My sense,” Moore said, “is that when you examine the challenges facing some smaller athletic departments, what we are seeing is a microcosm of the larger issue of income inequality simply playing itself on the intercollegiate landscape.”